Critically Evaluating Modern Firewall Technology

Assignment Brief

Assignment title: Critically evaluate modern firewall technology

Assessment task overview:

You will explore and critically evaluate firewalls that are being used within industry today  LO1: Critically evaluate firewall technologies linked to industry standards

Assignment task Element:

Written report Produce a report that critically evaluates different types of firewalls that are being used within industry. Critically reflect and contrast your findings on a range of software and hardware firewalls and their purpose within modern networks and with a view of current industry standards.

Sample Answer

Critically Evaluating Modern Firewall Technology

Introduction

Firewalls are an essential part of modern cybersecurity infrastructure. They act as a barrier between trusted internal networks and potentially harmful external traffic, enforcing security rules to prevent unauthorised access. As cyber threats have evolved, so too have firewalls, from basic packet filters to advanced systems incorporating artificial intelligence and deep packet inspection. This essay critically evaluates the different types of firewalls used in industry today, comparing their advantages, limitations, and compliance with current industry standards such as ISO 27001, NIST SP 800-41, and PCI DSS.

Evolution and Types of Firewalls

Early firewall technology emerged in the late 1980s as a simple packet-filtering mechanism that analysed network packets based on source and destination IP addresses, ports, and protocols. While effective for basic filtering, these early systems lacked the ability to inspect packet content, making them vulnerable to sophisticated attacks.

The introduction of stateful inspection firewalls in the 1990s marked a major improvement. Stateful firewalls, such as those developed by Check Point and Cisco, could monitor the state of active connections, allowing them to make filtering decisions based on the context of network traffic. However, as applications became more complex, attackers began exploiting application-layer vulnerabilities that these firewalls could not detect.

Modern network environments now rely on Next-Generation Firewalls (NGFWs). These systems combine traditional packet inspection with deep packet inspection (DPI), intrusion prevention systems (IPS), and sometimes sandboxing for real-time threat detection. NGFWs can identify specific applications regardless of port or protocol, enabling administrators to enforce granular policies. Vendors such as Palo Alto Networks, Fortinet, and Sophos are industry leaders in this category. According to Frost & Sullivan (2023), NGFWs now represent over 60% of enterprise firewall deployments globally due to their adaptive and intelligent threat detection capabilities.

Another development is the use of Web Application Firewalls (WAFs), designed to protect web servers and applications from attacks like SQL injection and cross-site scripting. Unlike network firewalls, WAFs operate at the application layer (OSI Layer 7) and are crucial for organisations hosting customer-facing platforms. Leading examples include AWS WAF, Cloudflare WAF, and Imperva.

Cloud-based firewalls, often referred to as Firewall-as-a-Service (FWaaS), have emerged with the rise of distributed and remote workforces. These systems, such as those offered by Zscaler or Azure Firewall, provide scalable and centralised protection across cloud networks without requiring physical hardware. FWaaS aligns with zero-trust architecture principles by enforcing access controls based on identity rather than location.

Hardware vs. Software Firewalls

Hardware firewalls are dedicated physical devices installed at the perimeter of networks, often used by enterprises for high-throughput environments. They are reliable, tamper-resistant, and capable of handling large volumes of data with minimal latency. Examples include Cisco ASA, FortiGate, and Juniper SRX. However, they are costly to implement and maintain, requiring physical space and ongoing firmware updates.

Software firewalls, on the other hand, are typically installed on individual devices or servers. Windows Defender Firewall and Linux’s iptables are common examples. They provide flexibility and are suitable for small to medium enterprises or personal use. Nevertheless, they may consume local resources and depend heavily on correct configuration to prevent vulnerabilities.

A hybrid approach, combining hardware and software solutions, is increasingly common. For example, large organisations often deploy hardware firewalls at the network perimeter while using endpoint software firewalls to secure internal systems. This layered defence, known as defence-in-depth, is consistent with the ISO 27001 framework, which recommends multiple layers of security controls to mitigate risk.

Continued...