Effect of Temperature on Chrysalis Development

Assignment Brief

This assignment consists of two parts.

1. 25% of the grade will come from a column graph showing the average number of days in a chrysalis for each temperature. The graph does not have to be computer-generated, but should be neat, accurate, and properly labeled. It will need a descriptive title, labels for the X and Y axes, and the graph should accurately reflect the data. Don’t overcomplicate the graph; although the table shows detailed data, the only data you need for the graph are the three temperatures and three averages! Below is an example of a simple column (or bar) graph. This particular graph shows the number of students preferring four different juices; you will be plotting the average number of days in the chrysalis for each temperature: cool, room, and warm. For your graph, you will have three “bars” or “columns.”
2. 75% of the grade will come from a paper of between 1000 and 1500 words, a minimum of 1000. The first part of the paper will focus on an analysis of the data to draw an informed conclusion about the experiment. This section will include ideas about how and why different temperatures affect the speed of metamorphosis. It should also include information from at least one similar study that validates or invalidates your conclusion and it should be cited at the end of the paper. The second part of the paper will focus on the effects of a changing climate on, not only insects, but also the communities and ecosystems they are part of. The paper should conclude with your ideas about the interconnectedness of all species in a community, and communities in an ecosystem, etc. This section should use two references. You may use one from the papers listed below. You may also use your textbook as a reference.

Sample Answer

The Effect of Temperature on Chrysalis Development and Implications for Ecosystems in a Changing Climate

Introduction

Temperature is a crucial environmental factor that influences the life cycle of insects, particularly during metamorphosis. This paper explores how varying temperatures impact the average duration of the chrysalis stage in butterflies and analyses how a changing global climate may affect insects and the broader ecosystems they inhabit. The first part of this paper analyses experimental data, including reference to similar research for validation. The second part extends the discussion to consider the ecological implications of climate change and the importance of biodiversity and interdependence within communities and ecosystems.

Part 1: Analysis of Temperature Effects on Chrysalis Duration

In the experiment, three temperature conditions, cool, room temperature, and warm, were tested to observe how they affect the average number of days that a butterfly remains in its chrysalis. Based on the experimental data, it was observed that warmer temperatures significantly reduced the time spent in the chrysalis, while cooler temperatures prolonged the metamorphic process. For example, at cool temperatures, the average chrysalis duration was approximately 18 days, while at room temperature it was 12 days, and at warm temperatures, it reduced further to 9 days.

This pattern can be explained through the effect of temperature on metabolic rate. In ectothermic organisms such as insects, external temperature regulates internal metabolic activity. At higher temperatures, enzyme activity accelerates, leading to faster biochemical processes and development. Conversely, cooler temperatures slow down metabolic functions, thereby delaying metamorphosis.

These findings are consistent with other studies. For instance, a study by Kingsolver et al. (2001) demonstrated that warmer environments hasten developmental rates in Manduca sexta (tobacco hornworm), a closely related species. The study found that for every 5°C increase in temperature, the pupation period decreased by approximately 20%, aligning with the observed trend in this experiment. Therefore, the conclusion drawn from this data, that temperature directly impacts metamorphic speed, is validated by existing scientific research.

However, it is important to note that excessively high temperatures can have adverse effects, such as deformities, increased mortality rates, or failure to emerge from the chrysalis. Hence, while temperature acceleration aids development to an extent, it has biological limits.

Part 2: Ecological Implications of Changing Climate on Insects and Ecosystems

As global temperatures continue to rise due to climate change, insects may face significant changes in their life cycles. Faster metamorphosis could lead to more generations per year (a phenomenon known as increased voltinism), which could have both positive and negative effects. On one hand, it might boost population sizes of beneficial pollinators. On the other hand, it could escalate populations of pest species, threatening agricultural productivity.

Furthermore, not all species respond equally to temperature changes. Some insects may adapt quickly, while others, particularly those with narrow temperature ranges, may experience population decline or extinction. These changes affect not only individual species but also the communities they inhabit.

Communities are networks of interacting species. Insects form the foundation of many food webs, serving as pollinators, decomposers, and prey. Their abundance or scarcity affects birds, mammals, and plants. For example, a decline in pollinating insects can reduce plant reproduction, leading to cascading effects on herbivores and their predators.

Additionally, climate-induced changes in insect populations can disrupt the timing of ecological events (phenology). For instance, if butterflies emerge earlier in spring due to warmer temperatures but their host plants have not yet sprouted, it may lead to starvation and population decline. This mismatch, called “phenological mismatch,” has already been documented in several ecosystems.

At the ecosystem level, changes in insect populations can impact nutrient cycling, plant community composition, and ecosystem services such as pollination and pest control. A study by Parmesan (2006) showed that global warming had caused range shifts in over 1,700 species, primarily affecting insects and birds, with ripple effects across entire ecosystems.

Continued...