United State Supreme Court Case Study

Assignment Brief

Directions:

You are to select a U.S. Supreme Court case which was decided on in the last two sessions (October 2016-Present).

Study and analyze the case.

• What happened? Where did it originate? Who was involved? How and why did it reach the U.S. Supreme Court?
• How was the case decided? How did each of the nine justices decide?
• Decide if political ideology may have played a role in how the justices ruled.
• Finally, include your opinion on the case. Why did you choose this particular case? How do you feel about the decision the court made? Are you in favor or against the decision? Do you think it was fair? How would you have decided? Feel free to elaborate.

Sample Answer

U.S. Supreme Court Case Study: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022)

Case Background and Origin

Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization is a significant Supreme Court case that originated in the state of Mississippi. In 2018, Mississippi passed the Gestational Age Act, which banned nearly all abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy, except in cases of medical emergencies or severe fetal abnormalities. This law directly challenged the legal precedent set by the 1973 case Roe v. Wade, which guaranteed a constitutional right to abortion before fetal viability, generally considered around 24 weeks.

Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the only abortion clinic in Mississippi at the time, filed a lawsuit against Thomas Dobbs, the Mississippi State Health Officer. The clinic argued that the new law was unconstitutional and sought to block its enforcement. Lower federal courts, including the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, agreed with the clinic, ruling that the law was invalid under existing Supreme Court precedent. However, Mississippi appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, which agreed to hear the case.

Supreme Court Decision and Justices’ Opinions

The U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision on June 24, 2022, in a 6–3 ruling that upheld the Mississippi law and, more importantly, overturned Roe v. Wade. This decision effectively ended nearly 50 years of federally protected abortion rights, returning the power to regulate abortion to individual states.

Here is how the nine justices ruled:

• Majority Opinion (6 Justices): Justices Alito (who wrote the opinion), Thomas, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett, and Roberts (who concurred with the result but not fully with the reasoning) voted to uphold the Mississippi law. Five of them supported overturning Roe v. Wade completely.

• Dissenting Opinion (3 Justices): Justices Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan dissented. They argued that overturning Roe was an attack on women’s rights and undermined the court’s legitimacy.

Political Ideology and Judicial Decision-Making

Political ideology appeared to play a significant role in the court’s decision. The justices who voted in the majority were all appointed by Republican presidents, with the three most recent appointments (Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, and Barrett) made by Donald Trump, who explicitly promised to appoint justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade. The dissenting justices were all appointed by Democratic presidents and are considered liberal in their judicial philosophy.

The division reflects a broader ideological divide between conservative justices, who argue that the Constitution does not explicitly guarantee abortion rights, and liberal justices, who view such rights as implicit under the right to privacy and personal liberty.

Personal Opinion and Reflection

I chose this case because it is one of the most consequential Supreme Court decisions in recent history, with widespread social, legal, and political implications. It has sparked intense public debate about the role of the court, states’ rights, and women’s autonomy.

Continued...