Ethics and the success or demise of an organisation

Assignment Brief

Volkswagen case study

• To what extent ethics play a part in the success or demise of an organisation

Sample Answer

The Role of Ethics in Organisational Success or Demise: A Case Study of Volkswagen

Introduction

Ethics play a critical role in shaping the long-term success or failure of organisations. Ethical conduct affects how a company is perceived by customers, investors, and regulators, and directly influences reputation, legal standing, and financial performance. This essay explores the extent to which ethics contribute to an organisation’s success or demise, using the Volkswagen emissions scandal as a central case study. It critically examines how Volkswagen’s ethical failings led to significant reputational and financial damage, while also considering broader examples of how ethical behaviour can support long-term business success.

The Importance of Ethics in Business

Business ethics refers to the moral principles that guide the behaviour of individuals and organisations in the business world. Ethical practices include honesty, fairness, transparency, and respect for stakeholders and the environment. These principles are not only a legal requirement but also essential for building trust and sustaining competitive advantage.

Ethical conduct contributes to long-term organisational success in several ways. Firstly, it builds a positive reputation, attracting customers and employees. Secondly, it reduces the risk of legal penalties and regulatory scrutiny. Finally, it promotes internal cohesion, employee morale, and productivity. Conversely, unethical behaviour can result in legal fines, public backlash, loss of trust, and even business collapse.

Volkswagen Case Study Overview

In 2015, Volkswagen (VW), one of the world’s largest car manufacturers, was found to have installed defeat devices in diesel vehicles to cheat emissions tests. The company had marketed its cars as environmentally friendly, but in reality, they emitted nitrogen oxide pollutants up to 40 times the legal limit. The scandal became known as “Dieselgate.”

This deliberate deception was an ethical breach on multiple levels, involving dishonesty, environmental harm, and misleading stakeholders, including consumers and regulators. The consequences were severe and illustrate how ethics, or the lack of them, can cause organisational demise.

Impact of Unethical Behaviour on Volkswagen

The unethical actions of Volkswagen had immediate and long-term consequences, both financially and reputationally.

Financial Consequences

Volkswagen faced over $30 billion in fines, lawsuits, and vehicle recalls. The cost of legal settlements with the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and consumer compensation schemes was substantial. Additionally, the company’s stock value dropped by around 40% in the weeks following the scandal, demonstrating the market’s reaction to unethical conduct.

Reputational Damage

Volkswagen’s brand, previously associated with engineering excellence and environmental responsibility, was severely damaged. Consumer trust declined, and sales of diesel vehicles fell across Europe and the US. Many customers chose competitors with stronger ethical reputations.

Internal and Leadership Failures

The scandal revealed deep problems within VW’s corporate culture. Senior managers either knew about the defeat devices or failed to ask critical questions. A culture of pressure to perform, combined with a lack of ethical oversight, contributed to poor decision-making and risk-taking.

This internal environment reflects how unethical practices often stem from systemic issues, not isolated actions. Ethics must be embedded in organisational culture and leadership to prevent such failures.

Ethics as a Driver of Organisational Success

While the Volkswagen case shows the damage caused by unethical behaviour, many companies have succeeded because of ethical practices.

Example: Patagonia

Outdoor clothing brand Patagonia is well known for its commitment to environmental and social ethics. It uses sustainable materials, supports fair labour practices, and donates part of its profits to environmental causes. As a result, Patagonia has built a loyal customer base, enhanced its brand image, and maintained profitability. Its ethical stance has become a competitive advantage.

Long-Term Value of Ethical Conduct

Ethics contribute to long-term success by enhancing brand value, customer loyalty, and employee engagement. Ethical organisations are more likely to attract and retain talent, face fewer regulatory fines, and sustain public support. Ethical leadership also supports innovation and risk management, leading to more resilient organisations.

Continued...